Tommy the tank engine

This Tommy guardian works best in multi-player where he's not as strong in clue gathering.

With allies like Guard Dog and Beat Cop, he'll be OK taking damage and horror to use his ability. Access to Cherished Keepsake and Leather Coat help him stay alfoat, and when they are defeated they just get shuffled back into the deck for use later.

I chose Gravedigger's Shovel to help with clue gathering and solid fighting until Becky shows up, but obviously Becky is what you want taking up hand slots.

Even with Becky, you probably have enough resources for Physical Trainingto help through the mythos phase with will checks. If only he also got a motocycle, he'd be perfect.