Contraband

I think this card is gaining new life after the introduction of the M1918 BAR. Sure, it's ain't cheap. But in curent cardpool only 2 investigators can use this combo. Leo Anderson, who has access to a Lonely Wolf and Hot Streak(2), and Zoey Samaras, who gain resource when engage the enemy (and She can use Lonely Wolf as well). I finds M1918 as an excellent card for both trash mobs and bosses, but it requires a different approach than Shotgun or Lightning Gun. Both Venturer, and Extra are Ammunition pretty bad for M1918 BAR, and without Contraband, this card will not show its true potential.

Clash77 · 68
I agree. Custom Ammunition is probably the only guardian reload that is worth its salt because it can let you squeeze more shots out of the BAR. — Myriad · 1242
Sleight of Hand

Most people think guns when they think about this card, but imagine Rex Murphy pulling Strange Solution (Acidic Ichor) out of his sleeves, dealing 9 damage, and be ready to play that card normally the next round! Also great with a Flashlight.

Ezhaeu · 51
I have made a build for Rex containing this cards. https://arkhamdb.com/decklist/view/7301/acid-rex-1.0 — Clash77 · 68
Strange Solution

This card seems incredible at first glance. And it really is.

+2 damage is a dominant effect in this game, and cards that offer repeatable +2 damage are almost always outstanding. (Springfield M1903 is why I had to say "almost".) Compared to the other +2 damage weapons in the game, Acidic Ichor is way cheaper and more convenient. Think of Lightning Gun; Acidic Ichor is cheaper by 1 XP, 5 resources, and 2 hand slots. That's amazing. It's kind of bizarre that the faction that's the best at finding clues would get a combat card as sweet as this, but that's how it is.

Yes, you need to identify the solution. But that basically boils down to spending a couple actions and passing an Intellect (4) test. Even on high levels, that's not much hassle.

As icing on the cake, Emergency Cache III is a quite efficient (albeit XP-intensive) way to reload this card.

So what's the catch?

Well, on lower levels, I would say there really isn't one. On Easy, Acidic Ichor will basically perform like a much cheaper Lightning Gun. That's every bit as good as it sounds.

On higher levels, though, and particularly on Expert, Acidic Ichor is no Lightning Gun. This is because attacking at base 6 is nowhere near enough. If you try to hit a 4-fight enemy without boosting (and most good targets for this card will have high fight), your odds of hitting are going to be substantially under 50%. You need to be able to boost your shots by a good +3 or +4 to make this card rewarding. Since Seeker decks tend not to be naturally loaded with Combat icons, that's not always easy.

Of course, you do have some options for getting that Combat up. You could run Overpower, Inquiring Mind, Unexpected Courage, maybe even Scientific Theory. Minh (easily the best Seeker at running Acidic Ichor) can take Lucky!, which helps an awful lot. Daisy might be able to get Encyclopedia to work out in certain situations. Maybe your allies have the spare cards to boost you. You have options. But it's difficult enough to hit with Acidic Ichor that the card is no longer a slam dunk.

I think Acidic Ichor becomes more of a build-around card on Expert. It's not something you can just throw into any Seeker deck and get good results. If you're in a multiplayer group and your allies are doing a good job handling monsters, devoting a lot of deck space and XP to Acidic Ichor may not be worth it. It can absolutely do great work on Expert if you put the effort in, but you do have to put the effort in.

CaiusDrewart · 3271
Side note, another players venturer can also recharge acidic icor. — Django · 5270
If we ever get seeker investigator with t — Clash77 · 68
Rex can do thys combo, but beside, venturer is not a real great card for him. But if we ever get seeker 5/guardian 2 investigetor :) — Clash77 · 68
Its okay if you were on say flashlights and sleight of hand as an additional support card. — Myriad · 1242
As I said OTHER Investigators can use their venturer on your strange solution. — Django · 5270
No longer true, with taboo. — MrGoldbee · 1603
Inquiring Mind

I believed this was a great card. I made the huge mistake to use it instead of Unexpected Courage

Location with clues are indeed plenty during the game, but what is the purpose of the Seeker class ? Empty them. And when it's empty, this card is a dead weight in your hand. You'll have to pay attention not to end your turn on an empty location, which requires too much planning and is often counter productive

Unexpected Courage will be enough in 80% of times, while half the time, Inquiring Mind will be completely useless, often at the wrost moment (Encounter deck draw)

Maybe in addition to 2 copies of Unexpected Courage, but even then, I'm not convinced.

NotSure · 24
It IS a great card, but yeah, not as a substitute of Unexpected Courage. It's great in Seeker class, especially if you have cards that like oversucceeding like Archaic Glyphs: Guiding Stones, or Deduction 2. Rex should especially consider it due to his special ability. Effects that place clues on your location also make this card more attractive. In my last run with this card I was playing a Roland Banks deck in the Carcosa cycle along with Quick Study and it almost never was a dead card in my hand. — matt88 · 3380
Quick Study might indeed change my mind. For the oversucceding bonus ? Yes, but only reliable for clue gathering if you don't a have clue dropping talent/ ally. In the end, It looks like the card is mostly used for 3xintelligence test (except maybe for Roland), while the real power should be it's versatiliy. — NotSure · 24
My thought process on this card when I put it in a Seeker deck (which is something I always do) is that I can always use it for investigations (which is the most common thing a Seeker does) and maybe I can use it for treacheries if I'm on the right spot, which is not totally necessary since you also have Higher Education (which is a priority upgrade most of the time). Then it can be useful against certain treacheries like Locked Door. For this one specifically it's especially useful since the location it will be attached to will always have clues, so you can always Inquiring Mind to help break it. — matt88 · 3380
Meant: You can always play Inquiring Mind to help break it (Sigh!) — matt88 · 3380
While some investigators can run this instead of Unexpected Courage, it can come back to bite you. I think with enough mobility, you can certainly run this over unexpected, or if you have effects that let you drop clues. — Myriad · 1242
I might be missing a rule detail here, but if I am at a location all the cards and tokens in my play area are at that location. This card says "a clue at your location" not "on your location", so if my investigator hat 1 clue, I can use this card even if there are no more clues ON the location. Right? — Ashiquor · 1
Lightning Gun

The more I play Guardian, the more I find myself turning to Lightning Gun as the best upgrade path for multiplayer Guardians. It is so good against the Expert chaos bag that if I don't build for it, I end up wishing I did. The +5 bonus means that with only modest further boosting you can crack the -8 token on every shot. The +2 damage means that you have to spend fewer fight actions to kill things, which means fewer pulls from the chaos bag and more actions left over to do whatever you need to do.

Of course, Lightning Gun very much demands to be built around. You must have ways to reload it in your deck--Extra Ammunition and Custom Ammunition are your best in-faction options here, and both are worth it. I think Venturer is fine, and I might run one or two. But my first choice would be to play the ammo events and use my ally slot elsewhere.

I recommend supplementing Lightning Gun with extra-damage effects--Beat Cop II and Vicious Blow are the most important. These save you ammo, skill tests, and actions by letting you kill 4-health (sometimes even 5-health) enemies in one action. Beat Cop II will also spare you from having to use Lightning Gun on something dinky like an Acolyte or Whippoorwill.

Beyond that, Prepared for the Worst to tutor Lightning Gun is very helpful, as is Stick to the Plan so you can start every game with that and other support cards available.

You were probably running Emergency Cache in most of your Guardian builds anyway, but it's as necessary here as anywhere else.

One support item I generally omit is Bandolier. I don't think there's a huge advantage to having the third hand slot, and Bandolier + Lightning Gun + another hand item is needlessly expensive. That said, you do always want additional assets in play to go with Lightning Gun. Otherwise you'll risk losing your Lightning Gun to stuff like Crypt Chill and Pushed into the Beyond, and that would just be disastrous. Just use assets that don't take up hand slots.

I would skip "Eat lead!" most of the time--the guaranteed hit is nice, but spending extra ammo and 2 XP isn't. Maybe if someone is packing Double or Nothing this becomes better, but it's probably still a low priority.

Make no mistake, this is a very greedy card. Most of your resources and much of your deck space will have to be devoted to it. It will take up a ton of XP, in a faction that is entirely devoid of XP acceleration. Attractive XP options like Stand Together will have to be significantly delayed, if you ever get to them at all.

But the upside is that a properly supported Lightning Gun will be outstanding at your primary task of blowing up enemies. You will do that far more efficiently and reliably than you otherwise could. Plus, when it comes time for a boss fight, you'll be ready.

CaiusDrewart · 3271
I'm with you on lightning gun! Zoey wants her blessed lightning gun to hunt monsters! The combo with venturer can work with Leo though and he can have the XP boost with Charon's obol! — mogwen · 254
@mogwin: Yep! I'm not a huge Charon's Obol fan but Leo is at least tanky enough that he could seriously consider it. If I were pursuing this build as Zoey, I would definitely take Delve Too Deep. — CaiusDrewart · 3271
Yes, good idea! And Father Matteo could give her dustom munitions, I like the idea of the religious party! — mogwen · 254
Note that e.cache 3 can recharge venturer for more ammo. Other players can use it on your venturer as well. — Django · 5270
Venturer does a lot for low ammo, high damage output weapons like this. Especially with other reload options. Lightening Gun is definitely the gold standard for big guns. — Myriad · 1242
Updating this review: while my opinion of Lightning Gun is more or less unchanged, I almost never buy this card nowadays. Flamethrower is just better. — CaiusDrewart · 3271